How to Build a Hiring Funnel That Attracts Top Talent Fast

Earnings Disclaimer: You have a .1% probability of hitting million-dollar months according to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics. As stated by law, we can not and do not make any guarantees about your own ability to get results or earn any money with our ideas, information, programs, or strategies. We don’t know you, and besides, your results in life are up to you. We’re here to help by giving you our greatest strategies to move you forward, faster. However, nothing on this page or any of our websites or emails is a promise or guarantee of future earnings. Any financial numbers referenced here, or on any of our sites or emails, are simply estimates or projections or past results, and should not be considered exact, actual, or as a promise of potential earnings – all numbers are illustrative only.

You’re losing A-players before you even get a chance to interview them.

Not because your company isn’t good enough. Not because the compensation isn’t competitive. But because your hiring process is a mess.

You post a job. You wait for applications. You sift through hundreds of resumes. You schedule interviews. You drag the process out for weeks. And by the time you’re ready to make an offer, the best candidates have already accepted offers elsewhere.

Meanwhile, you’re left choosing between B and C-players because the A-players didn’t stick around long enough to see your brilliant offer.

Here’s what nobody tells you about hiring top talent: A-players don’t apply to job postings. They don’t wait around for your slow hiring process. And they definitely don’t tolerate uncertainty.

If you want to hire A-players consistently, you need a completely different approach. You need a hiring funnel that attracts, qualifies, and closes top talent fast.

Let me show you exactly how to build it.

If your business is already generating $100k+ per month, My Inner Circle is where you break through to the next level. Inside, I’ll help you identify and solve the bottlenecks holding you back so you can scale faster and with more clarity.

Why Traditional Hiring Processes Lose Top Candidates

Let’s start by understanding why the standard hiring process is designed to lose A-players.

Most companies do this: post a job on LinkedIn or Indeed, wait for applications, screen resumes, do phone interviews, do multiple rounds of interviews, check references, make an offer.

The whole process takes 4-8 weeks. Sometimes longer. Industry data shows the average time to fill a position is 42 days, and tech positions can take as long as 52 days.

And here’s the problem: A-players are off the market in 7-10 days. Research shows that referral hires are hired 55% faster than traditional candidates, highlighting the speed advantage of proactive recruitment.

They’re not sitting around waiting for your drawn-out process. They’re getting recruited actively. They’re getting offers from other companies. They’re being courted.

While you’re still scheduling your second round of interviews, they’ve already said yes to someone else.

But it’s not just about speed. It’s about the entire approach.

Traditional hiring is reactive. You wait for people to find you. You hope the right person applies. You pray they make it through your process.

That’s not a strategy. That’s luck.

A-players don’t leave things to luck. And neither should you.

Five-Stage Hiring Funnel for Recruiting A-Players

Here’s the framework that actually works for consistently hiring top talent.

It’s based on the same principles as a sales funnel. Because hiring is sales. You’re selling someone on joining your company instead of staying where they are or going somewhere else.

The funnel has five stages:

Stage 1: Sourcing – Finding A-players before they’re actively looking Stage 2: Outreach – Getting their attention and interest Stage 3: Qualification – Determining if they’re actually a fit Stage 4: Conversion – Moving them from interested to committed Stage 5: Closing – Getting them to sign and show up

Each stage has specific strategies and tactics. And if you execute them right, you can go from first contact to signed offer in 10-14 days.

Not 8 weeks. Two weeks.

Let me break down each stage.

How to Proactively Source Top Talent Before They Start Job Hunting

A-players aren’t on job boards. They’re already employed. They’re already performing well. They’re not actively looking.

So if you’re only posting jobs and waiting for applications, you’re fishing in the wrong pond.

You need to go find them.

Identify where A-players hang out

LinkedIn is obvious. But it’s not the only place.

GitHub for engineers. Dribbble for designers. Twitter for marketers. Industry-specific communities and forums.

Figure out where the best people in your industry are visible and active.

Build a target list

Don’t spray and pray. Build a specific list of people you want to recruit.

Look at competitors. Look at companies known for talent. Look at who’s winning awards or speaking at conferences or publishing great content.

Create a spreadsheet. Track names, current companies, LinkedIn profiles, any mutual connections.

Aim for 50-100 names to start. This is your sourcing pipeline.

Use your network

Your best hires will come from referrals. Always. Studies show that 67% of recruiters report shortened time-to-hire and 51% report lower costs when recruiting via referrals.

Ask your current A-players who the best people they’ve worked with are. Ask advisors. Ask investors. Ask people in your network.

Referred candidates close at 3-4x the rate of cold outreach. And they perform better once hired.

Monitor continuously

Sourcing isn’t a one-time activity. It’s ongoing.

Set up alerts. Follow people on LinkedIn. Track when they post about frustrations with their current job or when they hit work anniversaries (good time to be open to new opportunities).

The best time to recruit someone is before you have an urgent need. Build relationships early.

How to Write Recruiting Outreach Messages That Get Responses

Once you’ve identified targets, you need to get their attention.

And here’s where most people fail. They send generic InMails or emails that sound like every other recruiter spam.

“Hi [Name], we have an exciting opportunity at [Company]…”

Delete.

A-players get these messages constantly. They ignore them.

Your outreach needs to be different.

Personalize based on research

Before you reach out, spend 5-10 minutes researching them.

Read their LinkedIn. Check their recent posts. Look at what projects they’ve worked on. See if you have mutual connections.

Then reference something specific in your outreach.

“Hey Sarah, saw your post about scaling backend systems for high-volume traffic. That’s exactly the challenge we’re tackling at [Company] and I thought you might find it interesting…”

That’s 10x better than generic recruiter spam.

Lead with the opportunity, not the ask

Don’t lead with “Would you be interested in a role at our company?”

Lead with the problem. The challenge. The opportunity to do interesting work.

“We’re building [specific thing] that [specific impact]. It’s a hard problem that I think you’d find fascinating. Would you be open to a quick conversation about it?”

You’re not asking them to apply for a job. You’re inviting them to learn about an interesting challenge.

That’s a much easier yes.

Leverage warm intros when possible

Cold outreach can work. But warm intros work way better.

If you have a mutual connection, ask for an introduction. A warm intro from someone they trust is worth 100 cold messages.

“Hey [Mutual Connection], I’m looking to bring on a senior engineer and I’ve been really impressed with Sarah’s work on [specific project]. Would you be comfortable making an introduction?”

Most people are happy to help if you make it easy for them.

Follow up persistently but respectfully

A-players are busy. They might miss your first message. Or your second.

Don’t give up after one attempt.

I typically follow up 3-4 times over 2 weeks if I don’t hear back. Each follow-up adds something new – a different angle, a piece of content, an update on the company.

But I’m respectful. If someone says they’re not interested, I thank them and move on. No pressure.

How to Quickly Qualify Job Candidates Without Wasting Time

Once someone expresses interest, you need to qualify them quickly.

This isn’t about putting them through a gauntlet. It’s about determining fit fast so neither of you waste time.

The 15-minute screening call

First conversation should be short. 15-20 minutes max.

I’m trying to answer three questions:

1. Are they actually interested or just curious?
2. Do their skills and experience match what we need?
3. Are they realistically available in our timeframe?

I’m not doing a full interview. I’m not asking them to solve problems. I’m just determining if we should invest more time in each other.

If any of those three answers is no, we part ways. No hard feelings.

If all three are yes, we schedule a deeper conversation immediately. Not next week. Not when I have time. Immediately.

“This sounds like a great fit. Would you be open to a longer conversation? I’ve got Thursday at 2pm or Friday at 10am. Which works better?”

Speed matters. Strike while the iron is hot.

Ask disqualifying questions early

Don’t waste time on people who won’t work out for fundamental reasons.

If you need someone in-office and they only work remote, find out immediately.

If your salary range is $150K-$180K and they’re looking for $250K+, find out immediately.

If they can’t start for 6 months and you need someone in 30 days, find out immediately.

Better to disqualify fast than discover deal-breakers after investing hours in interviews.

Look for red flags

A-players are professional. They’re responsive. They’re prepared for conversations. They ask smart questions.

If someone is hard to schedule with, shows up late without notice, or seems disengaged – those are signals.

Maybe they’re just not that interested. Maybe they’re not as strong as their resume suggests. Either way, pay attention.

You’re qualifying them, but they’re also qualifying you. If they’re not engaged, that’s data.

Efficient Interview Process for Evaluating Top Candidates

This is where you actually assess their skills and cultural fit. But you do it efficiently.

Most companies do 4-6 rounds of interviews. That’s insane for most roles.

Here’s what I do instead.

One deep technical/skills interview (60-90 min)

Depending on the role, this might be a technical screen for engineers, a portfolio review for designers, a strategy case for marketers, etc.

The goal is to assess whether they can actually do the work at the level you need.

I include 2-3 people from my team in this. We coordinate beforehand so we’re not asking duplicate questions.

We leave time for them to ask us questions. This is a two-way conversation.

One culture/values interview (45-60 min)

This is where we assess fit with our team and values.

I ask behavioral questions. I want to understand how they work, how they communicate, how they handle conflict, how they approach problems.

I also have them meet 2-3 people they’d work with closely. Chemistry matters.

One executive interview (30-45 min)

For senior roles, I want them to meet the CEO or relevant executive.

This accomplishes two things: it lets leadership assess them, and it shows the candidate we’re serious about them.

A-players want to know the leadership team is strong. This is their chance to evaluate that.

That’s it. Three conversations max.

The entire process from first call to final interview can be done in one week if you’re organized.

Week 1: Screening call Monday, technical interview Wednesday, culture interview Thursday, executive interview Friday.

Week 2: Make offer.

Compare that to the typical 6-8 week process. You’ve just compressed it by 75%.

How to Close Top Candidates Before Competitors Make Offers

You’ve found someone great. They’re interested. You’re interested. Now you need to close them before someone else does.

Move fast on the offer

Don’t deliberate for days. Don’t wait for the “right time.” Make the offer quickly.

If I finish final interviews on Friday, I’m making an offer Monday morning. Not the following week. Monday.

Speed signals interest. Delays signal uncertainty. A-players pick up on that.

Make a strong offer

This isn’t the time to lowball. A-players know their worth.

Do your market research. Know what top talent makes. Then offer at the high end of that range or above it.

Yes, it costs more. But an A-player who performs at 3x the level of an average player is worth 3x the cost. Easy math.

Also consider equity, benefits, flexibility, learning opportunities. Total package matters, not just salary.

Handle objections immediately

If they have concerns, don’t wait. Address them right away.

“The commute is longer than I’d like.” “What if we did 3 days remote, 2 days in office?”

“I’m concerned about the learning curve.” “Let me connect you with [team member] who joined 6 months ago from a different background. They can share their experience.”

“I have another offer I’m considering.” “I get it. What would help you make a decision? What questions do you still have about us?”

Don’t be passive. Be proactive in removing obstacles.

Create urgency without being pushy

You need a decision relatively quickly. Not because you’re impatient, but because the role needs to be filled and you’re talking to other candidates.

“We’re really excited about you joining the team. I do need to let you know we’re making decisions this week because we have other candidates in process. I don’t want to pressure you, but I also don’t want you to miss this opportunity. What would help you make a decision by Friday?”

This is honest and respectful. You’re not manipulating. You’re just being transparent about the timeline.

Stay engaged until start date

Offers fall through. People get counteroffers. They get cold feet.

Between offer acceptance and start date, stay in touch.

Send them company updates. Introduce them to the team. Invite them to optional events. Make them feel like they’re already part of the team.

The more connected they feel before day one, the less likely they are to back out.

Pre-Boarding Strategy to Keep New Hires Engaged Before Day One

Most companies think hiring ends when the offer is signed. That’s a mistake.

The period between offer acceptance and start date is critical. This is when buyer’s remorse kicks in. This is when other companies make counteroffers.

Here’s what I do to keep candidates engaged:

Send a welcome package

Company swag. A handwritten note from the CEO. Maybe a book related to their role or our company values.

Make them feel welcomed and valued before they even start.

Set up coffee chats

Introduce them to their future teammates. Set up informal video calls. Let them ask questions and start building relationships.

The more connections they have, the harder it is to back out.

Share onboarding materials early

Give them access to docs about the company, the team, the projects they’ll work on.

Let them start learning before day one. It reduces first-week anxiety and gets them excited about diving in.

Check in weekly

A quick text or email. “Hey, really excited for you to start. Let me know if you have any questions.”

It shows you care and keeps you top of mind.

How to Systemize Your Recruiting Process for Consistent Hiring

Once you’ve got the funnel working for one hire, you need to systematize it so you can hire consistently.

Create role scorecards

For each role, define exactly what success looks like. What skills are required. What experiences matter. What values are non-negotiable.

This makes it easier to assess candidates consistently and avoid bias.

Build interview guides

Standardize your interview questions. Make sure everyone on the hiring team knows what they’re assessing and how.

This speeds up the process and improves quality of assessment.

Track your metrics

How many people are you sourcing? How many respond to outreach? How many make it through qualification? What’s your offer acceptance rate?

Track this stuff. It tells you where your funnel is breaking down.

If you’re getting low response rates on outreach, your messaging needs work.

If lots of people are declining offers, your compensation or pitch needs work.

Data tells you what to fix.

Always be sourcing

Even when you’re not actively hiring, keep building relationships with A-players.

Add people to your network. Have coffee chats. Stay in touch.

When you do need to hire, you’ve got a warm pipeline ready to go.

Five Hiring Mistakes That Cost You Top Talent

Let me save you some pain by pointing out the mistakes I see constantly.

Mistake #1: Optimizing for efficiency over speed

“Let’s batch all the interviews for next week so it’s easier on our calendar.”

No. Speed matters more than your convenience. A-players won’t wait.

Mistake #2: Death by committee

Involving 8 people in the hiring decision doesn’t make it better. It makes it slower and more political.

Keep the interview panel small. 3-4 people max. Make decisions quickly.

Mistake #3: Focusing on credentials over capability

A-players don’t always have perfect resumes. Sometimes they have unconventional backgrounds.

Focus on what they can do, not where they went to school or what companies they worked at.

Mistake #4: Selling too hard

If you have to convince someone to join, they’re not that excited. And if they’re not excited, they won’t perform well.

Your job is to present the opportunity honestly and let them decide. Not to pressure them into accepting.

Mistake #5: Not moving fast enough

I can’t stress this enough. The #1 reason you lose A-players is because you’re too slow.

Compress your timeline. Make decisions quickly. Move with urgency.

Should You Hire a Recruiter or Build Your Own Talent Pipeline

“Should I hire a recruiter or do this myself?”

Depends on your situation.

If you’re hiring for a common role and you have time to build a pipeline, do it yourself. You’ll save money and build valuable recruiting skills.

If you’re hiring for a highly specialized role or you need someone yesterday, a good recruiter can be worth it.

But don’t outsource the entire process. You still need to be involved in outreach, interviews, and closing.

A recruiter can source candidates and coordinate logistics. But the relationship building and decision making needs to be you.

And if you do use a recruiter, make sure they understand your urgency. Most recruiters work on 30-60 day timelines. You need someone who can move in 10-14 days.

How to Adjust Your Hiring Process for Different Position Types

The funnel I described works for most roles. But you need to adapt it based on what you’re hiring for.

For senior leadership roles

The process is longer. These people need to meet more of the team. They need to understand strategy deeply.

But the principles are the same. Source proactively, move fast, make a strong offer.

For junior roles

You can afford to be more reactive. Junior people are more likely to apply to job postings.

But you still need to move fast. Junior A-players get multiple offers. Don’t assume they’ll wait for you.

For contract or freelance roles

The process can be even faster. Sometimes you can go from first contact to signed contract in 48 hours.

But qualification matters more. You need to be crystal clear on scope and expectations.

Four-Week Plan to Transform Your Hiring Process

If you’re currently using the traditional post-and-pray approach, here’s how to transition to this funnel.

Week 1: Build your target list

Identify 20-30 people you’d love to hire. Don’t worry about whether they’re looking. Just build the list.

Week 2: Start outreach

Reach out to 5-10 of them. Test your messaging. See what works.

Week 3: Refine and scale

Based on response rates, refine your approach. Then reach out to more people.

Week 4: Start interviewing

As people express interest, move them through your qualification and conversion process quickly.

Within 30 days, you should have your first hire from this approach. Or at least several promising candidates in your pipeline.

Compare that to posting a job and waiting. Which approach sounds faster?

Long-Term Benefits of Building a Proactive Recruiting System

Here’s what’s beautiful about building this hiring funnel.

Once you’ve got it working, hiring stops being a crisis and becomes a system.

You’re not scrambling to fill roles. You’re always building relationships with A-players. You’re always sourcing. You’re always one conversation away from your next great hire.

Your competitors are still posting jobs and hoping. You’re proactively recruiting the best talent before they even consider leaving their current jobs.

That’s a massive competitive advantage.

The companies that win are the ones with the best teams. And the best teams are built by the best hiring systems.

Not by luck. By design.

So stop waiting for A-players to find you. Go find them. Build the funnel. Execute with urgency.

Most business owners waste years figuring out what actually works. In my Master Internet Marketing program, I compress that learning curve into 7 weeks — covering copywriting, funnels, ads, and more. If you’re ready to invest $5k and get serious about your skills, apply here.

Your future team will thank you.