Stop Getting Burned & Start Scaling: The No-Excuses Playbook for Hiring Marketers Who Actually Make You Money

Stop Getting Burned & Start Scaling: The No-Excuses Playbook for Hiring Marketers Who Actually Make You Money

I hope you enjoy reading this blog post. If you want my team to just do your marketing for you, click here.

Author: Jeremy Haynes | founder of Megalodon Marketing.

Stop Getting Burned & Start Scaling: The No-Excuses Playbook for Hiring Marketers Who Actually Make You Money

Table of Contents


Earnings Disclaimer: You have a .1% probability of hitting million dollar months according to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics. As stated by law, we can not and do not make any guarantees about your own ability to get results or earn any money with our ideas, information, programs or strategies. We don’t know you and, besides, your results in life are up to you. We’re here to help by giving you our greatest strategies to move you forward, faster. However, nothing on this page or any of our websites or emails is a promise or guarantee of future earnings. Any financial numbers referenced here, or on any of our sites or emails, are simply estimates or projections or past results, and should not be considered exact, actual or as a promise of potential earnings – all numbers are illustrative only.


Watch the full video breakdown on this topic here.


🔑 Key Takeaways (Read These Twice)

  • Own the outcome. If you keep complaining that “another agency screwed me,” look in the mirror first. You hired them, you set the guardrails (or you didn’t), and you wrote the checks that went up in smoke.
  • Math before money. A properly-built financial model—complete with conservative, mild, and ambitious KPI scenarios—must precede every dollar of ad spend. Guessing is gambling.
  • Cash beats revenue. Model your funnel on cash collected today, not theoretical revenue tomorrow. Your credit-card billing cycle and payroll don’t care about long-term payment plans.
  • Bottleneck analysis is your X-ray. Find the choke point that’s strangling flow through your funnel, double the easiest metric, and watch profit surge without spending an extra penny.
  • Vetting is simple when you know the numbers. One interview question—“Which metric would you fix first, and why?”—exposes posers in 30 seconds.
  • Structure deals so everyone wins. Align incentives, bake in backup plans, and keep the upside asymmetric in your favor.

📑 Table of Contents

  1. The Accountability Gap: Why You Keep Getting Burned
  2. The Non-Negotiable First Step: Build the Financial Model
  3. Budget Myths & The Curse of “I Know What I Need”
  4. Dissecting the Call Funnel: A KPI Autopsy
  5. Scenario Modeling: Conservative, Mild, Ambitious
  6. Case Study #1 – $30 K Budget, Webinar-Plus-Call Hybrid
  7. Bottleneck Analysis: Turn Choke Points into Cash
  8. The One Question That Outs Fraudulent Agencies
  9. Case Study #2 – The Challenge Funnel Rescue
  10. Deal Points, Incentives & Alignment
  11. Closing the Education Gap & Next Steps

1. The Accountability Gap: Why You Keep Getting Burned

Another week, another entrepreneur whining that some “dog-food marketer cremated my ad dollars.” The pattern is so predictable it’s painful. You hand your growth over to someone you never vetted, you toss them a credit card, and you pray. When the campaign falls flat, you sprint to the nearest Facebook group to rage-post about “snake-oil agencies.”

Here’s the hard truth: every time you point a finger, three point back at you. You chose them. You didn’t demand a quantified plan. You never asked what the fallback strategy looked like if KPIs tanked. That abdication of responsibility is the precise reason you’ll keep buying tickets to the same financial slaughterhouse.

Until you own the hiring process, the math, and the monitoring, you’ll keep getting torched. Full stop.


2. The Non-Negotiable First Step: Build the Financial Model

Before a single impression is purchased, you need a mathematically backed plan that spells out:

  1. The conversion mechanism (call funnel, webinar, challenge, sales page—whatever).
  2. Every micro-KPI from CPM all the way to cash in bank.
  3. Upper and lower tolerance bands for each metric.
  4. Gross and net ROAS at conservative, mild, and ambitious performance levels.

No model, no money. If your prospective agency can’t show you a spreadsheet with hard numbers, walk.

Why Most Owners & Agencies Skip the Math

After mentoring 4,000+ agency owners, I’m stunned by how few insist on financial modeling. They “feel” an offer will convert and “believe” $20 K in ad spend should be plenty. Belief has never written a check that cleared. Math does.

The Cash-Collected Lens

Revenue is a liar; cash collected is honest. Model the actual dollars that hit your merchant account today. Separate lines can track deferred revenue, but your near-term P&L lives or dies on cash collected—which is why it belongs front and center in every KPI sheet.


3. Budget Myths & The Curse of “I Know What I Need”

Owners love to announce, “I have a $20 K ad budget, and I want it on this funnel.” If you truly knew what you were doing, you’d hire an in-house operator at a lower payroll cost and keep focus 100% on your brand. Declaring the tactic before the math is ego masquerading as strategy.

Real professionals reverse the order:
Model → Decide funnel & spend → Execute → Monitor → Optimize

Often the model reveals that your prized funnel needs either triple the budget to succeed or a smaller test on an entirely different path. Let the numbers, not vanity, dictate direction.


4. Dissecting the Call Funnel: A KPI Autopsy

Let’s walk through a call funnel example the right way:

StepMetric to Track
Ad deliveryCPM (e.g., $55)
InterestLink CTR vs. overall CTR (1.37 % vs ? %)
CaptureOpt-in rate (if any)
QualifyApplication rate & cost per application
ScheduleCall-booking rate
SegmentQualified vs. unqualified call cost
Show (Call #1)Show rate (e.g., 72 %)
Transition (if 2-call close)2nd-call booking/show rates
CloseClose rate (e.g., 45 %)
MonetizeCash-collected AOV, not topline
ReconcileGross ROAS → subtract ads, agency fee, sales commissions, COGS → Net ROAS

Plug your real numbers into that flow and you’ll instantly see where profit hemorrhages. Most owners discover their “winning ads” collapse once you layer in agency fees and commissions. Better to learn that in Excel than with a maxed-out Amex.


5. Scenario Modeling: Conservative, Mild, Ambitious

Now triplicate your model:

  1. Conservative – Assume every metric is as bad as you can stomach before you’d pull the plug.
  2. Mild – Slightly pessimistic but realistic; what most call “conservative.”
  3. Ambitious – Reasonably positive yet still tethered to reality. No unicorn fantasies.

Example: A client running $5 K/month in ads wants to jump to $100 K. They copy-paste their $40 cost-per-call as gospel. In reality, scaling to $100 K may push that cost to $80–$90. Modeling those three scenarios in advance prevents shock and lets you pre-plan pivots.


6. Case Study #1 – $30 K Budget, Webinar-Plus-Call Hybrid

Backdrop: A seasoned entrepreneur once doing $1.4 M/month drops to mid-six figures. His cost per call has ballooned nearly 2×, yet his show rate holds an enviable 72 %. He’s got $30 K total ad juice and wants certainty.

Our Approach:

  1. Audit real data—never just the founder’s memory.
  2. Model three scenarios for two competing plans:
    • Plan A: pour $30 K into the existing call funnel once we optimize creative and targeting.
    • Plan B: spend the first 10 days hammering a live webinar (his performance superpower), pocket profit, then roll “house money” into the call funnel for the remaining 20 days.

Outcome: Both conservative models looked strong, but Plan B produced more revenue, accelerated learning, and insulated the founder’s cash flow. Because we had numbers, both parties agreed instantly—no guesswork, no blind faith.


7. Bottleneck Analysis: Turn Choke Points into Cash

Picture your funnel as a series of pipes. Water (traffic) flows until it hits a single rusted joint. Everything behind backs up. Bottleneck analysis is the wrench that widens that joint first, because doubling the easiest metric beats obsessing over vanity numbers.

The “Double Game”

Take our earlier webinar funnel stats:

  • CPM $55
  • Link CTR 1.37 %
  • Opt-in 32 %
  • Show 11 %
  • Pitch retention 80 %
  • Call-booking 30 %
  • Call show 50 %
  • Close 45 %

Ask: “Which metric can we double fastest?” An 11 % webinar show could hit 22 % with basic reminder sequences. That alone may triple net ROAS. Meanwhile, chasing a 6 % CTR when 2 %-4 % is elite wastes months.

Owners who grasp this can challenge an agency weekly: “What’s the current choke? What’s the plan to widen it?”


8. The One Question That Outs Fraudulent Agencies

During vetting, show them your real stats (even if ugly) and ask:

“With a net ROAS of 1.3, which metric would you attack first, and exactly how would you attack it?”

A pro will identify the choke, outline specific creative or funnel moves, and anchor it in math. A poser will mumble about “better branding” or “more content.” Ten-second litmus test, zero ambiguity.


9. Case Study #2 – The Challenge Funnel Rescue

Scenario: Another founder runs daily webinars to sell $300 challenge tickets, then upsells a $20 K program. Eighteen webinars a month, three hours each, CPMs through the roof, cost per purchase hovering at $500.

Diagnosis: The webinar itself is the bottleneck—massive friction before any money changes hands. We proposed driving cold traffic straight to the sales page with strategic upsells.

Proof: A separate client moved $50 K of ad spend from webinar promo to direct-to-sales-page and finished with $4 M in total revenue:

  • $600 K from challenge ticket sales
  • $3.4 M from $10 K upsells
  • 1.9× front-end ROAS before back-end coaching revenue

When numbers scream that loud, you fire any agency contractually forcing you into webinar purgatory—as two of our Inner Circle members recently did.


10. Deal Points, Incentives & Alignment

A good growth partnership is an upside-weighted, downside-protected equation:

  • Fixed fee + performance kicker. Ensures agency covers baseline costs but wins bigger only when you win bigger.
  • Clarity clauses. The exact model, KPI ranges, scenario thresholds, and bottlenecks under surveillance live in writing.
  • Pivot protocol. Predetermined triggers switch traffic from Plan A to Plan B (webinar → call funnel, for instance) without emotional debate.
  • Data transparency. Daily read-only access to ad accounts and CRM so shadows and surprises never form.

With incentives aligned, good agencies feel like partners, not predators.


11. Closing the Education Gap & Next Steps

If you still get scorched by marketers, it’s because you haven’t closed the knowledge chasm between where you are and where million-dollar-month operators live. Your primary job isn’t clicking buttons in Ads Manager; it’s mastering strategy, math, and accountability so you can hold executors to a standard that prints money.

Two Paths Forward

  1. Inner Circle – For companies already clearing $100 K/month who want to sprint toward (and sustain) seven-figure months. Thirty-plus entrepreneurs inside already cross $1 M every 30 days. No income claims—just battle-tested frameworks.
  2. Master Internet Marketing – A seven-week deep dive, each live class running 3-5 hours, complete with worksheets and expansive homework libraries. Many seven- and eight-figure founders enroll their entire marketing teams so everyone speaks profit fluently.

No matter the route, remember: knowledge precedes leverage. Guessing is for people who like setting money on fire. You deserve better.


Final Word

Your next agency engagement can be the catalyst to million-dollar months or another line item under “miscellaneous losses.” The difference is a spreadsheet, a handful of brutally honest questions, and the resolve to own every outcome.

Do the math. Spot the bottleneck. Vet with facts. Align incentives. And watch what happens when accountability meets expertise—because that’s where real scaling starts.

About the author:
Owner and CEO of Megalodon Marketing

Jeremy Haynes is the founder of Megalodon Marketing. He is considered one of the top digital marketers and has the results to back it up. Jeremy has consistently demonstrated his expertise whether it be through his content advertising “propaganda” strategies that are originated by him, as well as his funnel and direct response marketing strategies. He’s trusted by the biggest names in the industries his agency works in and by over 4,000+ paid students that learn how to become better digital marketers and agency owners through his education products.

Jeremy Haynes is the founder of Megalodon Marketing. He is considered one of the top digital marketers and has the results to back it up. Jeremy has consistently demonstrated his expertise whether it be through his content advertising “propaganda” strategies that are originated by him, as well as his funnel and direct response marketing strategies. He’s trusted by the biggest names in the industries his agency works in and by over 4,000+ paid students that learn how to become better digital marketers and agency owners through his education products.